Hayley Platt

Book Review: The Irishman's Daughter by V.S. Alexander

By Hayley Platt

The Irishman’s Daughter, written by V.S. Alexander, is a historical fiction tale set in 1845 in Carrowteige, County Mayo, Ireland. 

Readers follow the life of Briana Walsh, daughter of the agent of the property she lives on, called Lear House. The tale spans over eighteen months as Ireland sinks into the famine of the mid-1800s, with food becoming scarce and difficult to come by.

The plot of this novel is fairly slow-moving, following the lives of the characters closely. They are not exceptional people. They are an everyday family trying to survive the blight and trying to escape and grow without becoming casualties of the famine.

The beginning of the book transports the reader directly into the vivid greens and rolling hills of Ireland. We see the towns, villages, and local harbours. After reading a few chapters it is easy to picture the area around Briana and know the place she loves so dearly. As the famine sets in, the detail shifts to describe exactly what a terrible state the majority of County Mayo experiences with the loss of all potato crops. Readers see illness, starvation, theft, anger, sadness, and more. It is easy to feel compassion for the characters in this book because their circumstances are detailed so accurately, and they are not at fault for any of the outcomes.

A high point in the novel is when Briana marries her long-time childhood love Rory. However, not long after their vows they have to decide between their wish to save Lear House and their need leave to save themselves and their future. This impossible decision and the reasoning they use feels very real and easy to connect with. Readers follow Briana and Rory’s storylines through a large portion of the book, and it is not clear how the book will conclude and if a happily ever after will exist for them. 

During the quest to survive, readers are taken on horseback across the countryside to see for themselves the way the residents lived in small rural clusters. The heartbreaking tale challenges readers to picture themselves in similar situations to consider what choices they would make if necessary.  

This book is recommended for lovers of historical fiction, especially if you know some of the history in Ireland or are looking for learn more about how a community may degrade in a famine. 

 

Thank you so much to Penguin Random House Canada for the complimentary copy of The Irishman’s Daughter so it could be read and impartially reviewed.

Book Review: Wildwood Whispers by Willa Reece

By Hayley Platt

Wildwood Whispers by Willa Reece is the author’s adult fantasy debut novel. Her previous works are published under the name Barbara J. Hancock and span many genres including romance and fantasy. 

Wildwood Whispers is the story of Mel Smith, a young woman who grew up in the foster care system. She has one close friend, Sarah Ross, whom she met in one of the homes and stuck with until both were in their twenties. After Sarah’s sudden death, Mel is determined to return Sarah to her home town and is quickly drawn into the quirky and magical town of Morgan’s Gap, nestled in the Appalachian Mountains.

Coming in at just under 400 pages, this felt like a longer book that was on the slow side. The first part of the book is very heavy in description of people and scenery, which will appeal to many readers, but others will appreciate the uptick in the plot in the last third of the story. This book is definitely recommended to people who love to read about the woods and love to visualize the setting of a story as they move through the pages.

This was a true genre-spanning novel; parts of it were fantasy, romance, and mystery all rolled into one storyline. Overall, this mixing of genres was done well, but some aspects (the romance parts in particular) were very minor and could have either been embellished more or taken out and the story would have had the same effect. 

There are a lot of characters who help pull the story together, many with minor roles. At the beginning it is difficult to keep them straight but as the story begins to pick up it becomes easier to keep track of who you need to keep track of.

One consistent topic in this book is the need to protect the environment and our connection with nature. Many readers will be able to relate to the storyline because of this aspect alone.

This book is recommended to readers who love magical realism and books covering multiple genres at a time. This would be a great book for a book club or discussion group, since every person who reads it will pick up on different aspects and come away with their own conclusions about Sarah and Mel’s story.

 

Thank you so much to Hachette Book Group Canada for the complimentary copy of Wildwood Whispers so that it could be impartially reviewed.

Book Review: Every Summer After by Carley Fortune

By Hayley Platt

Every Summer After is Canadian author Carley Fortune’s debut novel, which was published May 10, 2022. This love story, told through six summers in the past and one eventful weekend in the present, takes readers to the heart of summers in a small Ontario cottage town, an experience many will easily connect with.

Persephone “Percy” Fraser is 13 when her parents surprise her by purchasing a summer property in Barry’s Bay and let her know that is where they will be spending their summers moving forward. Her first day there she heads down to the dock and meets the teen brothers next door, Charlie and Sam Florek, who are year-round residents in the sleepy town 

Everyone should pick up a debut Canadian novel this season, and Every Summer After is the perfect choice.

The setting of this book is extremely relatable for central Ontario cottagers. Percy’s family lives in Toronto, so Fortune was able to write from the familiar perspective of a teen who is headed to the cottage for the summer. There are many small towns in Ontario whose populations multiply in the summer months, and the experiences of both the summer-only and the year-round residents is spot on. Jumping off the dock, driving into town, and saying goodbye for ten months at a time perfectly wrap up the feeling of summer at a cottage.

In her later teen years, it is fascinating to see Percy realize that she knows Sam’s summer self really well but knows less about who he is the other ten months of the year. There is something really special about youthful summer friendships, and Sam and Percy’s builds in an attention-grabbing fashion that keeps readers glued to their books as the story progresses.

This romance is unique in that the reader gets to see the development of Percy and Sam’s relationship in both their teen years (ages 13–18) as well as the intricacies of an adult relationship in the present day sections. The long term effects of decisions they make when they are teenagers are investigated and grappled with in their adult lives.  Watching the relationship build in this way draws the reader into the heart of the story and keeps them rooting for the happily ever after that we all know and love.

Fortune has beautifully captured the summer magic that ties people together and can continue to exist many years down the road.

This book is recommended for people looking for a delightful summer read, especially those wanting to experience hitting the highway on Friday after work for a weekend on the dock. It is the perfect summer read.

 

Thank you so much to Penguin Random House Canada for the complimentary copy of Every Summer After in exchange for an honest review.

In Conversation with Heather Marshall author of Looking for Jane

With Hayley Platt

 

Photo Credit: Amanda Kopcic

 

I grew up in Toronto, where Looking for Jane is set, and I love being able to place myself in the shoes of the characters because I know the locations. Did you walk down the same streets your characters walked during the writing process? What about this location spoke to you?

This is a great question! I’m very familiar with the city, so it was easy to picture (or walk) the routes and locations described in the book. I really wanted it to feel like it was Toronto, not just any big city, which was why I included a lot of specific references to places like Massey Hall and Fran’s Diner. Although some landmarks have stayed pretty much the same (like the paths through Queen’s Park), the fun part of writing Toronto in the historical fiction genre was getting to do research on things like what the Sam the Record Man sign looked like in 1981 when Nancy is walking past it, because it changed a few times over the years.

Did you know from the beginning the way Evelyn, Nancy, and Angela’s stories would intertwine or did parts/characters come to you as you were writing? What was your process for writing this story?

So writers fall into two categories: plotters, who plan everything out in meticulous detail from the beginning (often utilizing impressive spreadsheets), and ‘pantsers’ who fly by the seat of their pants and figure it out as they go, scribbling down random ideas on napkins and the note app on their phone while they’re in the grocery line. As much as I would love to be a plotter (and have tried, and failed spectacularly), I’m definitely a pantser! But I find it allows for more flexibility in the creative process, because oftentimes while I’m writing, a new plot or character idea will occur to me and I like to have room to incorporate those new ideas as the story unfolds. With that said, with Looking For Jane, the last scene/chapter/line was one of the first things that came to me when I was thinking about writing this book, and one of the first segments I wrote. So I did know how it was going to end, and I sort of worked my way backward from there, interweaving Evelyn, Nancy, and Angela’s stories as organically as possible. 

Are parts of yourself written into any of the protagonists? As I’ll mention later, many women can identify with your characters, who do you identify closest with?

Funnily enough, I don’t *think* there is a lot of me in those characters, because with this book I very much felt like I was a scribe for other women’s stories. If I had to pick, I would probably say Angela. I can relate to her burning desire to get pregnant, and I think I also have a nosy/stubborn streak like she does. If I had found a letter with that kind of a confession in it, I know I wouldn’t have been able to just let it go, either! I would have needed to find the recipient. 

Was there anything you discovered while researching for this book that you found to be particularly shocking, intriguing, or surprising? What piece of information helped shape your story?

I had done some academic papers on the history of abortion access in Canada in the years leading up to the 1988 Supreme Court decision that decriminalized it in Canada, so as much as those stories were appalling, I was not *shocked* by them. The most shocking research for me was the maternity home system. I had only ever heard about ‘homes for unwed mothers’ in a very vague sort of way, and hadn’t thought much about it. But when I dug into that research and learned what those women (girls) had gone through, it was beyond heartbreaking. I couldn’t believe this was never in my history books, and I knew I wanted to shed some light on it. But it was an incredibly emotional research process, and I tried to make sure I was depicting their experiences as accurately as possible. I wanted to do it justice. 

You've written a story that many women will be able to identify with, either from shared experience or family history, was this your goal when you started writing Jane or did it occur organically?

I knew I wanted to tell a story about the history of women’s reproductive rights in Canada over the past several decades, and then the book and its messages developed from there. I really wanted to show the evolution of how far we’ve come, and in some ways how far we still have to go, which was why I decided to do this sort of sweeping story that covered several decades. And I think that’s one of the reasons the book has resonated so much, because for women of almost any age, there is at least one part of this story that occurred during their lifetime/formative years, so they can really put themselves in the shoes of these characters. A lot of the experiences and struggles, in one way or another, are quite universal. 

Has your perception of the book changed now that you are a mother?

Absolutely. I wrote it before I was even pregnant, then was editing it while pregnant and when my baby was a newborn, and it hit so differently at that point. I have a much clearer view of what the girls at the maternity homes would have gone through, having their babies forcibly taken from them, and also how a woman might feel trapped if she was pregnant and didn’t want to be. As far as the research process went, though, I’m actually really glad I wrote it when I did, because I’m not sure I could have handled that research now that I’m a mother. 

Are you currently working on another book? What can we expect next from you?

Yes! I’m just finishing up the first draft of my next novel, which is also historical fiction. I can’t say too much just yet, but it’s inspired by the life of a woman named Mona Parsons, who was the only Canadian civilian woman to have been sentenced to death and imprisoned by the Nazis during WWII. Her story also wasn’t in my history books, and it’s just incredible. I’m looking forward to shedding some much-deserved light on her life! 

What advice would you give to aspiring authors who are trying to navigate the publishing world?

I know it’s so difficult, I’ve been there, but patience and perseverance are essential. Looking For Jane wasn’t actually the first book I wrote. I have another manuscript that will likely never see the light of day; it never got picked up by an agent (mostly because I didn’t do my market research beforehand, so be sure you do that, too!). If you’ve been pitching your manuscript to agents for a while and just aren’t getting any bites, come up with another idea and try again! It can be a really tough slog, and sometimes take years, and often it feels very hopeless, but if you’re determined enough, you can do it. Keep at it. Some of the best advice I got on the publishing process was from a writing instructor who told me “you only have to have two of three things: a great book, perseverance, and a bit of luck.” Take your time, and don’t rush the process. Research the market, research agents thoroughly to make sure you’re targeting the right ones, pay attention to the format in which those agents want your manuscript pitched to them, and keep trying! In the meantime, take writing courses and keep writing. The more you write, the better you get.

What is your “must-read” book recommendation and what book has had the most impact and influence on your writing?

Oh my gosh! What a question. If I had to pick just one, I would say All the Light We Cannot See by Anthony Doerr. It’s a Pulitzer Prize winning book for a reason. It is nothing short of a masterpiece. He has a way of capturing the human experience in a way I’ve never seen from any other author I’ve ever read; it’s so succinct while being gut-wrenchingly profound. If I could hone my talent to even one tenth of his, I would be satisfied. And as a writer, it’s good to read books that are so incredible that they leave you feeling inadequate! You’ll only get better at tennis if you play against someone who’s better than you.

Book Review: Looking for Jane by Heather Marshall

By Hayley Platt

Canadian author Heather Marshall’s debut novel Looking for Jane, published on March 1, 2022, expertly investigates some of the hard truths for unmarried women in the latter half of the twentieth century, alongside a message of hope and resilience in the present.

In 1960,  teenager Evelyn Taylor is dropped off at St. Agnes’s Home for Unwed Mothers by her father. She is there to wait out her pregnancy, put her baby up for adoption, and then return home, reputation unscathed.

In 1979, Nancy Mitchell finds herself rushing her cousin to the hospital following an unsafe abortion in a basement apartment. She is quietly told by one of the doctors what to do if she is ever in this situation again.

In 2017, Angela Creighton is going through fertility treatments to conceive a child following a few unsuccessful attempts and early miscarriages. While at work in an antique shop, she finds a letter written in 2010 that did not make it to its destination. Angela is determined to reunite the letter with its intended recipient.

Evelyn, Nancy, and Angela’s timelines slowly intertwine as the women work through the challenges put in front of them, leaving readers curious and determined to see the pieces fall together.  

Looking for Jane is a book that readers will be able to identify with. Just as no person comes to motherhood in the same way, Angela, Nancy, and Evelyn face different challenges on their paths to ultimately find peace from the events in their lives. Each of their storylines tackles issues surrounding women’s reproductive rights from a different perspective, and each protagonist has secondary characters in their life that enhance the story and give further insights into the challenges that can surround a pregnancy.

Heather Marshall set the majority of this book in Toronto, describing places that existed in the earlier timelines and still do today. It is easy to imagine you are right beside the women as they fight for their rights while expertly protecting their motherhood.

Looking for Jane dives deep into the maternity home system that existed in Canada, as well as women’s reproductive rights in the 1970s and 1980s. The concluding author’s note identifies some of the pieces of history this book has drawn from, including the network of ‘Janes’ in Chicago (an underground service that assisted and supported women through the abortion process) that elements of the book were modeled after. Marshall’s background includes education in history and work in politics, and she has expertly used her background to complement the narrative. She is using her voice not only to tell a story but also to educate and encourage readers to search out more information and act after reading her work.  

An astounding number of families have a history in maternity homes, with pregnancy loss, abortions, adoptions, and fighting for women’s rights. Looking for Jane showcases that it doesn’t matter how you come to motherhood, a mother is a mother, and that’s what’s important. Every reader will find some connection between parts of this book and their own life. 

For an exploratory look at the birth and adoption process in Canada’s not-so-distant past presented in a great historical read, pick up this book today! Also, don’t miss our fantastic interview with the author, Heather Marshall!

Thank you so much to Simon and Schuster Canada for the complimentary review copy of Looking for Jane so that it could be impartially reviewed.

Book Review: The Last Train to Key West by Chanel Cleeton

By Hayley Platt

The Last Train to Key West, published in June 2020, is a historical fiction novel set in 1935 in the Florida Keys when one of the most powerful hurricanes recorded passed through the area.  

Helen Berner lives in the Keys with an abusive husband and is nine months pregnant when the hurricane heads into town. Mirta Perez is brought to the Keys on her honeymoon with her new husband before they head to New York City permanently. Elizabeth Preston travelled to the Keys from New York and is hoping to find a missing family member who is likely in the camps where many veterans of the Great War are living. The book is set during the Great Depression, and even though that is not the focus of the storyline, readers can see how it has impacted each of the characters and how they deal with conflict.

The book is told from all three of their perspectives, but it is easy to keep each storyline straight as the author has mastered writing each of their perspectives in its own way. 

Cleeton has woven the stories of Mirta, Elizabeth, and Helen seamlessly as they prepare for and live through the hurricane. She has shown the strength and determination women of the time had, having lived through the war and the beginning of the Depression before encountering this extreme weather. All three women start off in Key West but travel separately to the town of Islamorada, where they weather the storm, each in their own way. At the end of the book, readers are left feeling satisfied with no major plot holes. It is clear how each storyline has come to a neat conclusion.

The Floridian landscape has a unique feeling, and the descriptions of the setting easily transport readers into the page alongside Cleeton’s heroines. As the storm rolls in, it is impossible to miss the darkness and worry within the pages.

In addition to the primary tale of surviving the hurricane, each perspective pulls in details about secondary storylines and history that may not be expected in historical fiction surrounding a specific event. Examples of this would be the lives of some army men following the war in the work camps which can be found in Elizabeth’s chapters. Helen’s chapters include fishermen at the time and the struggles women encountered in abusive relationships in the 1930s. Mirta’s chapters brought in background information about the Cuban Revolution in 1933. All of these topics added to the story paint a detailed picture of the lives of each of the women.

In addition to the spectacular writing, the cover design was developed using an image of a model from the cover of an issue of Vogue in 1952 superimposed onto an image of Key West.

This book is recommended to historical fiction lovers, especially those looking for stories set in the USA during the Great Depression. 

Book Review: The Apollo Murders by Chris Hadfield

By Hayley Platt

The Apollo Murders (published in October 2021) is a novel following the Apollo 18 mission set in 1973. It is written by Canadian Astronaut Chris Hadfield, and it is clear from the beginning that the technical details of the writing are accurate. Overall, this book fits into many genres, including science fiction, mystery and thriller, and historical fiction.

The story follows the crew and support and ground staff, beginning from their preparations to go to the moon through to the return of the crew to earth. The thriller aspects of the book come from the race to space during the cold war era, and as the title eludes, a murder or two.

Though this book is heavy in technical details, the writing flowed smoothly. Details are described using language that can be understood by readers with various backgrounds, and no prior knowledge of the themes presented is required to enjoy the story. Reading The Apollo Murders will give you enough information to begin to understand and appreciate the complexities of space travel. About one hundred pages in, the story shifts from background and story building and dives into the mystery and thriller storyline-- from there, it’s difficult to put down.

Instead of being split into traditional chapters, The Apollo Murders is split into larger sections based on where in the mission the crew is. Within these sections there are shorter segments told from different perspectives, which keeps readers quickly flipping pages.

There are a few instances throughout the novel where there are mechanical failures onboard the spacecraft. During these times, Hadfield takes us into a flashback of sorts to the point in time where there was an error in construction or design of the particular piece, who was working on it, and some of their history. This was a really interesting way to get a glimpse at how long and detailed the construction of a piece of machinery like this can be.

In real life, the Apollo program ended after Apollo 17, so it is clear that this book is fiction, but also falls within the realm of possibility. A note at the beginning of the book indicates that many of the characters are real, many of the events actually happened, and the novel is bookended with a comprehensive list of each of the real people and things with some explanation. Sections like this, explaining exactly what is historical and what is fiction, are always appreciated in historical fiction books.

The Apollo Murders is a complex and detailed novel that seamlessly merges sci-fi with the historical challenges of its era. It is recommended to both thriller and space lovers—and of course, fellow fans of Chris Hadfield.

Book Review: Letters Across the Sea by Genevieve Graham

By Hayley Platt

Letters Across the Sea is a Canadian historical fiction novel that starts out in 1933 and follows main characters, Molly and Max, through World War 2. Early in the book—summer 1933—it depicts a fairly unknown protest that occurred in Toronto’s Christie Pits and how unrest in the city grew leading into the war.

Molly Ryan is the middle child of five in an Irish Protestant family. She is their only daughter and has had to drop out of high school early to help support her family through the Depression.  Molly has big dreams to become a journalist but is stuck working any job she can find. Max Dreyfus, a Jewish boy, whose sister Hannah is Molly’s best friend, is going away to study to become a doctor at the end of the summer. He can’t stop thinking about Molly and what he wishes their relationship could be. Before he can leave, the conflict between their two communities comes to a head, and conflict between their families ends all possibility of their relationship.

The story then moves forward to 1939 when Max has been deployed with Canada’s Royal Rifles and Molly is working at The Star, a Toronto newspaper. She spends her days at work reporting about the war and time at home sending and receiving letters from her brothers overseas.

Letters Across the Sea is written from both Molly and Max’s perspectives.  When the book begins, Molly is eighteen and we follow her life for more than a decade as she navigates the changes in the world around her from the Great Depression through the war. She is challenged by the hatred she encounters towards Jews in Canada but is put in a difficult position trying to speak up against her family, and in support of her oldest friend’s family, the Dreyfus’.   

As a Canadian author, Genevieve Graham has done a great job finding a small piece of Canadian history and masterfully weaves it into this engrossing World War 2 historical fiction novel. It ties an event in Toronto to many of the more well-known events of the era. Readers are given a glimpse at how events all across the battlefronts of World War 2 could be connected into one family at home. 

After reading this novel, I was pleased to find maps and photographs included in the note to readers that confirms what aspects of the novel come from fact and which were a product of the author’s writing.

All historical fiction fans as well as anyone looking to learn more about Canada’s history, what it was like in Toronto during the Depression and how Canadian troops were deployed in Europe will appreciate this book.  

Book Review: The Forest of Vanishing Stars by Kristin Harmel

By Hayley Platt

Forest of Vanishing Stars.jpg

The Forest of Vanishing Stars, published in July 2021, is a World War II historical fiction novel set mainly during the 1940s. It is a captivating story about the Jewish people who survived the Holocaust by moving into the dense Polish forests and living off the land.

The protagonist, Yona, is two years old when she is taken from her bed in Berlin by Jerusza, who is almost eighty years old. The two of them live in the Polish forests, where Jerusza gives Yona an unconventional education that covers learning multiple languages, practical first aid, how to survive in the wilderness with few traditional supplies, and significant self-defence, including how to kill someone. Shortly after Jerusza dies at the end of the winter in 1942, Yona begins finding other Jewish people who are fleeing the Nazis and attempting to survive by living in the woods. Yona dedicates herself to helping the people she encounters survive the war. 

This novel follows a chronological timeline, beginning in 1922 and quickly moving into the expected years of WWII. It is told from the third person perspective, but there is still significant character development on Yona’s part, and it is easy to understand her perspective and reasoning. It is particularly interesting watching Yona learn what it is like to interact with other people, as she has spent almost two decades with only Jerusza in the woods. Readers get to see her adapt to living in a communal setting with a group of people who have differing opinions and a need for both leadership and compromise. We also see her learning about romantic love and heartbreak, which can be unexpected in this subgenre of historical fiction.

Another unexpected, yet welcome, aspect in this book was the magical realism that Jerusza and, to a lesser extent, Yona are surrounded by. Jerusza believes that she knows things that other people don’t, and many of her actions are based around what she knows the future will hold. Her reason for kidnapping Yona at the beginning of the book is tied to her knowledge of far off events. Yona is less connected to this magical aspect. She knows when dark things are looming, but her foresight is not as prominent.

Harmel ends this book with a lengthy author’s note detailing where pieces of this story come from and where she did her research while writing. She outlines conversations she had with a Holocaust survivor who spent years in the Black Forest and survived some similar events to Yona and the people she travels with.  From a reader’s perspective, this is greatly appreciated. It helps ground the story by separating the historical from the totally fictional.

Those who seek out the lesser known Holocaust stories and World War II historical fiction will appreciate this book.